By now some of you have probably heard of Greg Paul's situation on the Dinosaur Mailing List. His posts there have generated a lot of controversy, but without taking any particular side here, in short the issue is about the very real problem of paleoart plagiarism, namely of those scammers who blatantly copy Greg Paul's specific works verbatim for paid projects, often also underbidding him and making it that much harder to earn a living from paleo-art. So with good reason, he's threatening to sue the plagiarizers (and possibly museums or publishers who hire them for a pittance instead of going to Greg Paul and paying a fair price for the real "Greg Paul look").
However, he's also suggested that others not even use similar poses in their skeletal restorations. The classic "Greg Paul pose" with the left foot pushing off, is apparently something he wants to make into an exclusive brand. Unfortunately this is already a very common pose among skeletal artists and there are only so many ways you can pose a profile skeletal and still have it be accurate. Copyrighting poses raises a specter of slippery slopes where if every artist copyrighted different poses, eventually it would be impossible to draw an accurate skeletal without being sued. Instead of stopping intellectual property theft, this could stifle legitimate creativity. Skeletals of different artists look noticeably different, even when the poses are the same, i.e., a Scott Hartman skeletal looks different from a Greg Paul skeletal.
Now admittedly there are others on ArtEvolved whose knowledge of these issues is far better than mine, so what do you all think about this? I understand copyrighting poses from a particular live scene of dinosaurs - after all, to copy those, you have to replicate not just the pose but the exact angle too. But with skeletal drawings the default angle is always a side view, and there are not very many ways to accurately pose is given our current knowledge of paleontology. Can poses really be copyrighted for skeletals? Should they be? Or is this a Pandora's Box of legal disaster for paleo-artists?
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(265)
-
▼
March
(57)
- The Palaeo-Environment Project
- Two girls at the beach, Portugal, 1930
- Great Britain stamp: King George VI coronation, 1937
- Ask a Biologist
- TIME RUNS OUT
- .flickr-photo { border: solid 2px #000000; }.flick...
- Sunbathing in Portugal, 1930
- Sunbathers in Portugal, 1930
- Summer Gallery poll is up!
- Martha Mansfield
- Pink Dinosaur #249 - The Lost Elias
- Black silk pajama, 1930
- "Dinosauri in Carne e Ossa" the great italian Pale...
- WORDS THAT SHOULDN'T BE ILLUSTRATED
- Illustration by Tom, 1930
- Scott Hartman's Epic History of Skeletal Drawings!
- Millard Sheets, San Dimas Train Station, c. 1935
- Evan Boucher's Thoracosaurus
- Sears Catalogue, 1926
- Trilobite Boy featured on io9
- Ilustração, No. 111, August 1 1930 - 40
- Sisters G : Karla Gutchrlein
- Cover by Ilberino dos Santos, 1930
- I own Greg Paul's Albertoceratops!
- The new "Bone Wars" - David Tana's take on GSP
- Queen of Portugal Maria Amélia, 1930
- The Ball of the Empire, 1930
- ART Evolved's Ask a Biologist Initiative!
- epic GSP
- Ilustração, No. 109, July 1 1930 - 42a
- Philosofossilising: The Gregory Paul Emails
- Thank you for all your great support whth the Save...
- Artist Help Japan
- Animals
- Beauty queen, 1930
- Society Wedding, 1930
- Greg Paul threatens legal smackdown!
- Noirat Hairdressing, 1921
- Pandora's Pencil Box: are there limits to artists'...
- svpow Stomp!
- Parasol
- Marlene Dietrich, Joan Crawford and Norma Shearer,...
- Mad Art Lab, a new science/art blog from Skepchick
- Summer Fashion, 1930
- Colouration Input
- I'll be dedicating a few speed paints to the Sauro...
- Anchor Tricoton, 1936
- Glendon Mellow Interview at Love in the Time of Ch...
- Beni Hunziker, Masked Ball in the animal kingdom, ...
- The "Sun King". Our newest wall lamp in brass with...
- Making a Dinosaur in Carrara (Spline Technique)
- New Palaeo-Art Blog
- Sauropod Romp Rumble...
- ONE LOVELY DRAWING, part 35
- The Terror Bird Gallery
- TAD's Greatest Hits
- The May Gallery
-
▼
March
(57)